[Yoda]

Great answer, Lynn.

Simple is always better.

If you do not want to respond to the strengths and weaknessness of these two perfectly 1-L compliant procedures, I completely understand.

But, maybe some of the others will comment.

Is it a 100-0 victory for one method over the other? or is there possible advantages to one over the other.

Let's keep this on topic, if possible.

For all but the most adroit, we are into the specious argument of 'how many angels can dance on the head of a pin."

www.bartleby.com/59/4/howmanyangel.html

Keep your Head steady.

It is the First Essential of The Golfing Machine®.

Or, assuming you can tell a difference, keep the 'base of your neck' steady.

Your Body is a Rotor. Your Arms and Club are the Blades. No matter how it is driven, the Left Arm and Club always moves in a circle.

Do what Vardon, Jones, Palmer and Nicklaus were told to do:

"Stand still, and as you take the Club away, let your Body Turn, not Sway."

If you do that, you've got a chance to play this Game well.

If you don't, you better bring a lot of talent and a ton of time to the table.

Because you're doing it the hard way.