[YodasLuke]

It is my understanding that Homer's on-plane concept is a general concept designed to keep the clubshaft on-plane throughout the entire swing and not specifically targeted to keeping the clubshaft (or sweetspot) on-plane in the immmediate vicinity of the impact zone. I think that if a golfer gets his clubshaft on-plane throughout his entire swing, then he has developed an idealised clubhead arc that will in-to-square-to-in and that will enable him to square the clubface at impact.

Did I miss something, or did we not cover this subject? I would suggest that the perect scenario would be to have the CG constantly On Plane and to have the Clubshaft On Plane most of the time.

Here is my idea of an idealised clubshaft on-plane swing - Anthony Kim's swing.

I think I understand Toolish's point earlier in the thread. And, I've always said that I'm not a big fan of Plane conversations with bad camera angles. Kim's a great specimen, but it's still a bad vantage point.

If you're the guy looking on the same plane as the fragments of debris that create the rings of Saturn, you'd insist you were looking at things traveling in straight lines. If your eyes move off of that plane, you'd insist you were looking at circles.

I would spend a lifetime in 2-J-1, 2-J-2, and 2-J-3.